PRTravelwire

PRTravelwire is a tourism focused distribution channel with a focus on the Caribbean.
6 minutes reading time (1111 words)
Featured 

U.S. Tourism Office Has Put Out Inaccurate International Visitor Data For Years

Tourism-and-Travel

Source: https://skift.com 

So new questions are being raised about the so-called Trump Slump, the decline of foreign visitors to the United States since the president came into office. As Skift's Dan Peltier reported on Monday, the Commerce Department has suspended releasing data for now because it believes its numbers showing such a decline may be inaccurate.

But now Skift has learned this may not be some short-lived statistical glitch, but a more systemic problem.If true (and who knows what passes for truth in Washington these days) Commerce has a much larger problem on its hands that will have huge implications for the travel industry, in the U.S. and abroad. Companies rely on that information to be accurate to make business plans and projections, launch marketing campaigns, and communicate with shareholders.

Travel executives have a right to be concerned and question what went wrong. Skift will stay on top of this story to get those answers and dig out the truth — remember that?      Tom Lowry, Managing Editor 

Many U.S. destinations and travel companies expect accurate international arrivals data from the U.S. National Travel & Tourism Office, but documents obtained Tuesday by Skift show flaws have existed in the data collection process for years and that the U.S. Department of Homeland Security has been reluctant to correct errors. 

Data is an increasingly key pillar of any industry, and particularly for the travel industry. Inaccurate data reporting has the potential to impact companies and destinations beyond the United States, but many destinations and companies aren’t waiting around for National Travel & Tourism Office data as they use a handful of sources to understand who’s getting off planes, boats, busses, and cars in their locales. 

The U.S. Department of Commerce, which oversees the National Travel & Tourism Office, announced on Monday that it plans to suspend further releases of international arrivals data until technical issues are resolved, according to a statement from the agency.

Skift first reported that news. Data is only currently available through September, 2017, when international arrivals were down 5 percent year-over-year and 3.8 percent year-to-date. Canadian arrivals were up more than 4 percent for September and year-to-date, but Mexico and overseas arrivals fell more than 6 percent for the month and first three quarters. 

The U.S. Travel Association, which represents travel industry sectors in Washington, D.C, issued a statement Monday that it praised the Department of Commerce’s decision to suspend further data releases. 

The organization later defended its position and said it began to notice discrepancies in I-94 arrivals records, or paper and electronic forms that record international arrivals via land, sea, or air, and challenges with collecting accurate data, since the latter half of 2017. The U.S. Customs and Border Protection agency, part of the Department of Homeland Security, collects travelers’ I-94 records and shares them with the Department of Commerce. 

“We’ve been engaging with the administration since the latter half of last year because based on other inputs we use in our own research, we thought the I-94 data might have some anomalies with it and that it wasn’t providing an accurate picture,” said Chris Kennedy, a spokesperson for U.S. Travel. “There have been a number of engagements since.” 

The Commerce Department did not respond to Skift’s request for comment on Tuesday. But a former National Travel & Tourism Office researcher said inaccurate data reporting goes back further than last year. At the Travel and Tourism Research Association conference in June, 2017, Ron Erdmann, a former deputy director of research for the National Travel & Tourism Office who retired in December, gave a presentation about the state of I-94 records. 

Erdmann said problems have become apparent since the Department of Homeland Security started to automate I-94 data collection in 2013. “Early on we had issues with transit passengers being counted as visitors and no way to track visits to one night or longer,” Erdmann’s presentation said. In 2014, the National Travel & Tourism Office started to use the United Nation’s World Tourism Organization‘s definition of international arrivals — those who spend one or more nights in a destination. 

Erdmann said data quality increased dramatically as a result, but more problems occurred in late 2014 and are still ongoing. Those problems include the loss of the country of residency for certain visa waiver program countries due to kiosks and other entry processing technology, the presentation said. 

More than seven million I-94 records from 2015 are missing country of residency information, according to the presentation, and 3.1 million records were missing such information in 2016, which amounts to 8.5 percent and 5.3 percent, respectively, of all records for 2015 and 2016. 

Other missing data from 2015 and 2016 records include mode of transport data, automated passport control and mobile passport apps not collecting country of residency information, and cross-coding of some countries such as China, Hong Kong, Turkey and Turkmenistan. 

When reached Tuesday, Erdmann said: “They told us that they were going to do another reengineering, and this suspension might be a signal that they might be close to fixing this. (Homeland Security) doesn’t really care about the big numbers, they only care about the individual.” Some destinations like Philadelphia don’t view data suspension by the Department of Commerce’s move as detrimental to their operations. 

The National Travel & Tourism Office’s data is only one international arrivals data source that Philadelphia uses, said Alethia Calbeck, a spokesperson for the Philadelphia Convention & Visitors Bureau, and it’s not weighted heavily enough to have a significant affect on the organization’s overall reporting. “Although we recognize the seriousness of the situation as its important for our industry’s advocacy efforts, it won’t impact our reporting as we – like many other U.S. destinations – use Tourism Economics as our source for international arrival and spend data,” said Calbeck.

“In Tourism Economics’ model, [National Travel & Tourism Office] data is only one of 10 sources used.

”CONGRESS WANTS ANSWERS

U.S. Senators Brian Schatz, Amy Klobuchar, Dean Heller, and Roy Blunt — a bipartisan group of senators who are co-chairs of the Senate Travel and Tourism Caucus — echoed Erdmann’s claims of problematic data in an April, 2018, draft letter addressed to Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen.

The senators said the Department of Homeland Security hasn’t done enough to fix the problems. “We were heartened to hear that DHS staff does address the data discrepancies as they are pointed out but after more than 3 years the data is still not being delivered with consistent accuracy,” the senators said in the letter.

“We would like to see these data issues addressed in a comprehensive and systemic manner so that the American public and travel and tourism sector can have full confidence in the data and reports they receive from the federal government, and their ability to plan for providing services and travel experiences to international travelers.”

Tourism Commissioner Tells Partners USVI Open for ...
Airbnb is rolling out a new tier aimed at higher-e...
 
This website is protected by RSFirewall!, the firewall solution for Joomla!

front1

AccessJamaica

Theo Chambers
05 October 2015
Hotel
Tourism
The long-standing friction between hoteliers and OTAs was kicked up a notch last week as the trade associations representing each of those groups engaged in a war of words and data over “rogue” OTA w...
Theo Chambers
14 July 2016
Caribbean
Tourism
Costa Rica
Cuba
Panama
Source: Travel Weekly - THE TRAVEL INDUSTRY'S TRUSTED VOICEWhat’s the top influence when making travel plans? For nearly three-quarters (74%) of global travelers, it’s “going somewhere I’ve never...
Theo Chambers
09 July 2013
Meetings
Just days after hosting the Caricom Heads of Government Summit, T&T will be the venue for another regional gathering.  On July 16 and 17, the ACS Secretariat in Port-of-Spain will host the 2...
Theo Chambers
20 May 2014
Entertainment
Banjul, West Africa. May 17, 2014. Sizzla Kalonji is a liberator with a cause and simultaneously, the Cultural Ambassador for the 11th staging of the Gambia Roots International Festival in Banjul, We...
Theo Chambers
10 July 2014
Entertainment
Basseterre, St. Kitts (July 10, 2014) – The mix of musical talents and genres that was showcased on stage at the 18th annual St. Kitts Music Festival held June 26-28, 2014 led to patrons and visiting...
Theo Chambers
10 May 2016
Hotel
Tourism
Moms think they know best.And, you know what? We agree.Source: Hotel News ResourceIn addition to reminding us to clean our rooms, comb our hair, and be nice to our teachers, Moms love to shower us wit...
Theo Chambers
23 March 2015
Health
Montego Bay, Jamaica, W.I. (March 22, 2015) Patricia Berry-Greenidge has crisscrossed the Atlantic and Caribbean Seas in her quest to bring ITEC (International Therapy Examination Council) standards ...
Theo Chambers
08 April 2016
General
(Flight Centre Award) NEW YORK, NY; April 7, 2016: Minister of Tourism, Hon. Edmund Bartlett (3rd right), was presented with a Telly Award by Brennan Quesnele, Flight Centre USA Inc’s&...
Theo Chambers
23 June 2016
Hotel
Tourism
Source: tnoozThe company has been talking about it a lot recently, not least at a conference I attended.Whilst many gushed and appeared in awe, it gave a really great opportunity to hear, instant...
Sharon Parris-Chambers
07 January 2018
Caribbean
CARICOM’s incoming chairman, Jovenel Moise of Haiti, says the absolute necessity to create a climate smart region is clear, given the effects of climate change which have brought destructive hurricane...
Theo Chambers
15 July 2016
General
Caribbean
Hotel
Tourism
Economic
Source: Hotel News ResourceTravel Prices Set to Marginally Increase or Remain Flat for 2017; Geopolitical and Economic Uncertainty Mean Travel Managers Need to Remain Flexible and Agile New resea...
Theo Chambers
20 June 2016
Caribbean
Tourism
Transportation
Source: The Wall Street JournalBy SUSAN CAREYThe two carriers were among six that won route rights to secondary airports in Cuba.Silver Airways Inc., a Florida-based operator of turboprop planes,...
Theo Chambers
09 July 2013
Transportation
The shipment of the first four lock gates for the third set of locks for the Panama Canal has begun in Italy. They are expected to arrive in Panama by the end of August. Boarding operations began...
Theo Chambers
10 July 2013
Transportation
Budget Car RentalPress releaseVisitors to the Caribbean Can Fully Enjoy the Island Experience With the Perfect Vehicle From Budget Car RentalPARSIPPANY, N.J., 2013-07-10 16:00 CEST (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -...
Theo Chambers
20 August 2013
Transportation
The friendly island of St. Maarten continues to prove itself as a preferred destination for travelers with a 12.1% increase in Canadian passenger traffic during the first six months of 2013 compared ...
Theo Chambers
21 August 2013
Environmental
Basseterre, St. Kitts and Nevis, Aug. 20 (CNA) Republic of China President Ma Ying-jeou visited a solar power plant being built by a Taiwanese company in St. Kitts and Nevis on Monday to highlight th...
Theo Chambers
26 March 2014
Entertainment
The Gambia invites the African Diaspora to return to a grand homecoming to embark on a spiritual journey of healing and reunification May 9-17, 2014. The Gambia International Roots Festival is a call...
Theo Chambers
26 July 2014
Entertainment
MONTEGO BAY, JAMAICA –Minister of Tourism and Entertainment, the Hon. Dr. Wykeham McNeill (shown right in the photo) explains plans to use Jamaica’s entertainment and culture to drive visitor arrival...
Theo Chambers
27 January 2015
Transportation
Knutsford Express is pleased to announce some long-awaited news about new schedules, as well as, new stations. Knutsford Express has included a stop at Gutters (at the end of Spur Tree Hill) alo...
Theo Chambers
07 March 2015
Sports
Montego Bay, Jamaica: March 4, 2015: The Jamaica Tourist Board (JTB) has thrown its full support behind the upcoming MoBay City Run, describing the charity event as an asset to the development o...
Theo Chambers
25 March 2015
Health
A total of 10 spa therapy professionals recently graduated with their diploma in holistic massage from the Ocho Rios-based, Personal Body Health Care (PBHC) Clinic and School of Holistic Therapies, b...
Theo Chambers
12 February 2016
General
ATLANTA (January 11, 2016) – In a bold, unprecedented move, today Bronner Brothers, Inc. (BB) announced it has assembled a preeminent group of celebrity stylists, beauty schools and motivators for it...
Theo Chambers
12 February 2016
General
Negril, Jamaica, W.I. January 18, 2016. Over thirteen years ago, Garry Sowerby, a four-time world record holder, long-distance driving, columnist and global adventurer, set out on an odyssey. On Frid...
Theo Chambers
03 April 2016
General
NEW YORK, NY - JetBlue today announced further expansion of Mint, its award-winning take on the premium experience, to two new Caribbean destinations – St. Lucia and St. Maarten – and on additional n...